Pricing a Maintenance Agreement, and the Point at Which the State Calls It a Service Contract

Devon Davila · 2026-10-26

A maintenance plan is two products in one contract. The first is scheduled maintenance: two HVAC tune-ups a year, a quarterly pest treatment, an annual water-heater flush. That part is priced from visit cost and is, in most states, an ordinary service agreement. The second is everything the plan promises if something breaks: a repair discount, waived diagnostic fees, priority response, parts coverage. That part is what state law calls a service contract or service warranty, and selling it requires registration, a licence, and insurance or reserves in every state we checked. The line between the two is drawn in the statutes, and several plans sold by contractors sit on the wrong side of it without knowing.

Quick answer: A maintenance agreement is priced from the cost of the visits it promises: loaded technician time for the drive and the on-site work, divided by utilization, plus mileage and consumables, divided by one minus your margin. What most plans add on top, a discount on repairs, priority scheduling, 'no diagnostic fee,' is where the law comes in. In Texas, Nevada, New York, Arizona and Illinois a contract that promises, for a separately stated price and a fixed term, to repair or replace a product for operational failure or normal wear is a 'service contract' that requires registration with the state and reimbursement insurance or reserves; a plan that 'provides only for scheduled maintenance' is expressly carved out in Texas, Nevada and New York. Florida regulates 'service warranties' and exempts a maintenance plan only if it is under one year, carries no indemnification and discounts parts and labor by no more than 20 percent; above that it needs an Office of Insurance Regulation licence, and selling without one is a misdemeanor. California defines a service contract to include maintenance as well as repair and requires registration with the Bureau of Household Goods and Services plus financial security. On tax, a cash-method business reports the plan fee when received; an accrual-method business may defer the unearned part one year under Treasury Regulation 1.451-8. On renewals, California's automatic-renewal law requires clear terms, affirmative consent, an acknowledgment and online cancellation; the FTC's 2024 click-to-cancel rule was vacated in 2025 and a 2026 rulemaking is open.

The line, in the statutes' words

The pattern is the model act every one of these states drew from: a "maintenance agreement" is "a contract of limited duration that provides for scheduled maintenance only" and is not a service contract; the moment the contract undertakes repair or replacement for failure, or indemnity, it is one. Florida sharpens the line with a number: a repair discount above 20 percent converts a plan.

StateWhat is regulatedWhat is carved outWhat selling it requiresVerified
TexasA "service contract" is "an agreement that is entered into for a separately stated consideration and for a specified term under which a provider agrees to" repair, replace or maintain a product, or indemnify for it, "for operational or structural failure or damage caused by defects or normal wear" (Occ. Code 1304.003)The chapter does not apply to "an agreement that provides only for scheduled maintenance for a limited period" (1304.004)"A person may not operate as a provider or administrator of service contracts sold or issued in this state unless the person is registered with the department." (1304.101, Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation)2026-10-26
FloridaA "service warranty" is "any warranty, guaranty, extended warranty or extended guaranty, maintenance service contract equal to or greater than 1 year in length or which does not meet the exemption in paragraph (a) … for a specific duration to perform the repair, replacement, or maintenance of a consumer product" (§634.401(13))Exempt: "Maintenance service contracts written for less than 1 year which do not contain provisions for indemnification and which do not provide a discount to the consumer for any combination of parts and labor in excess of 20 percent during the effective period" (§634.401(13)(a))"No person in this state shall provide or offer to provide service warranties to residents of this state unless authorized therefor under a subsisting license issued by the office." (§634.403, Office of Insurance Regulation); operating without one is a first-degree misdemeanor2026-10-26
Nevada"A contract pursuant to which a provider, in exchange for separately stated consideration, is obligated for a specified period to a holder to repair, replace or perform maintenance on … goods" (NRS 690C.080)The chapter excludes "a maintenance agreement," defined as "a contract for a limited period that provides only for scheduled maintenance" (690C.100)"A provider shall not issue, sell or offer for sale service contracts in this state unless the provider has been issued a certificate of registration" (690C.150)2026-10-26
New York"a contract or agreement, for a separate or additional consideration, for a specific duration to perform the repair, replacement or maintenance of property" (Ins. Law §7902)A "maintenance agreement" is "a contract of limited duration that provides for scheduled maintenance of property, other than contracts providing for the repair or replacement of such property due to a defect in materials or workmanship or wear and tear" (§7902)"No person shall act as a provider pursuant to this article without having first obtained an approval of a registration"; "a fee of two hundred fifty dollars for each year or fraction of a year," renewal "five hundred dollars" (§7907)2026-10-26
Arizona"A written contract or agreement for a separately stated consideration for any duration to perform … the repair, replacement or maintenance … for the operational or structural failure of a consumer product" (A.R.S. 20-1095)Not stated in the definitions; a plan that promises no repair of a failure sits outside the "operational or structural failure" language"A service company may not offer or issue a service contract unless the service company has qualified for and been issued a permit by the director." (20-1095.01, Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions)2026-10-26
Illinois"a contract or agreement whereby a service contract provider undertakes for a specified period of time, for separate and identifiable consideration, to perform the repair, replacement, or maintenance, or indemnification for such services, of any automobile, system, or consumer product in connection with the operational or structural failure due to a defect in materials or workmanship, or normal wear and tear" (215 ILCS 152/5)No separate maintenance-agreement term; the definition is keyed to "operational or structural failure"No contract may be "issued, sold, or offered for sale in this State unless" the provider carries reimbursement insurance or meets the net-worth or funded-reserve alternatives (152/15)2026-10-26
California"a contract in writing to perform, over a fixed period of time or for a specified duration, services relating to the maintenance or repair of a consumer product" (Civ. Code §1791(o)); "services relating to the maintenance, replacement, or repair of consumer goods" (B&P §9855)None in the definitions read: California's definition reaches maintenance as well as repair"It shall be unlawful for any person to act as a service contractor in this state unless that person first registers with the bureau" (B&P §9855.1, Bureau of Household Goods and Services), and financial security under §9855.2: a qualifying net worth, reimbursement insurance, an insured administrator, or an escrow "equal to a minimum of 25 percent of the deferred revenues"2026-10-26

Errata: what the ranking pages get wrong

ClaimReality
"A maintenance plan is a subscription; no special rules apply"Scheduled-maintenance-only plans are carved out in Texas, Nevada and New York. Add a promise to repair failures, and the plan is a service contract requiring registration and insurance or reserves in Texas, Nevada, New York, Arizona and Illinois, a licensed service warranty in Florida, and a registered service contract with financial security in California.
"Include a 25 percent repair discount to make the plan attractive"In Florida that one feature takes a sub-one-year plan out of the exemption, which stops at a discount "in excess of 20 percent," and into licensed service-warranty territory.
"Book the year's plan revenue when the card runs"A cash-method business does: "Under the cash method, you include in your gross income all items of income you actually or constructively receive during the tax year." An accrual-method business may defer the unearned part, but only to "the next succeeding taxable year" (Treas. Reg. 1.451-8).
"Auto-renew the plan every year unless they call"California B&P 17602 makes it unlawful to charge "without first obtaining the consumer's affirmative consent," to omit an acknowledgment with the cancellation policy, and to deny online cancellation to online sign-ups. The FTC's 2024 click-to-cancel amendments were vacated by a federal appeals court in July 2025; a new FTC rulemaking opened March 11, 2026, and the FTC Act's ban on deceptive practices never lapsed.
"Price the plan at two tune-ups minus a discount"Price it from cost: loaded time per visit, utilization, mileage, consumables, margin. Section 3.

Pricing the maintenance half

The inputs are the same public figures used in the companion reference on hourly rates: the BLS median wage for the trade, the BLS benefits ratio (30 percent of compensation, or 42.9 percent on top of wages), and the IRS mileage rate (76 cents per mile from July 1, 2026). The assumptions, utilization and margin, are yours.

Cost of one visit. (drive minutes + on-site minutes) ÷ 60 × loaded wage ÷ utilization, plus round-trip miles × $0.76, plus consumables.

Worked at the HVAC median ($29.33, loaded $41.91), 65 percent utilization, 25 minutes each way, 60 minutes on site, 20 miles round trip, $12 in filters and cleaner:

  • Labor: (50 + 60) ÷ 60 × $41.91 ÷ 0.65 = $118.21
  • Vehicle: 20 × $0.76 = $15.20
  • Consumables: $12.00
  • Visit cost: $145.41

Plan price at the maintenance level. Two visits a year at that cost are $290.82. At a 20 percent margin the plan is $290.82 ÷ 0.80 = $363.53, before anything the plan gives away. At a 30 percent margin, $415.46.

What the extras cost. Each feature beyond the visits is a liability with a cost and, in several states, a legal consequence:

  • Priority scheduling costs nothing in cash and does not promise repair. It is safe in every state above.
  • Waived diagnostic fee is a cash cost equal to the fee times the expected number of calls, and a promise tied to a failure. It is the first step toward service-contract status.
  • Repair discount is a cash cost equal to the discount times expected repair spend, and in Florida the exemption ends at 20 percent.
  • Parts or labor coverage is indemnity. It is a service contract or service warranty everywhere in the table, and it needs reimbursement insurance or reserves because you are now the insurer of the customer's equipment.

Deferred revenue, and why the states care. A prepaid annual plan is unearned until the visits happen. For tax, a cash-method business reports the fee when received; an accrual-method business may defer the unearned portion one year under Treasury Regulation 1.451-8. For regulation, the deferred balance is what the financial-security rules measure: California's escrow option is "a minimum of 25 percent of the deferred revenues," and Illinois's alternatives to reimbursement insurance are net worth and funded reserves. A contractor who has sold 300 plans has $100,000 of other people's money for work not yet done, which is exactly why the statutes exist.

Staying on the maintenance side of the line

A plan that keeps every state's carve-out available:

  1. Scheduled maintenance only, listed by visit and task. Two tune-ups, a filter change, a drain-line flush.
  2. A term of less than one year, renewed by affirmative consent, which keeps Florida's exemption open and satisfies California's renewal law.
  3. No indemnification: no promise to pay for, repair or replace anything that fails.
  4. Any repair discount at or below 20 percent, stated as a discount on your standard pricing, not as coverage.
  5. No "free" diagnostic tied to a failure; if you waive the fee, waive it for plan members on all visits as a pricing choice, not as a response to breakdowns.
  6. Clear renewal terms: the price, the term, the renewal date, how to cancel, and an acknowledgment at sign-up; online cancellation if the sign-up was online.

If the plan you want to sell needs the other features, it can be sold; it is a service contract, and the path is registration (Texas, Nevada, New York, Arizona, California), a licence (Florida), and reimbursement insurance or reserves (all of them). Several insurers write that coverage for contractors; the statutes name it.

Method and limits

Statutes were read at the legislature's site or a code mirror on the dates shown and the operative definitions quoted. Seven states are covered; most others have adopted a version of the NAIC model with the same maintenance-only carve-out, but each should be read before relying on it. Registration fees and financial-security amounts beyond those quoted were not pulled. The pricing section is arithmetic on the public inputs of the companion hourly-rate reference and on stated assumptions; it does not recommend a plan price. The Eighth Circuit's vacatur of the FTC's 2024 negative-option amendments is taken from legal-press summaries; the FTC's own 2026 release refers to "the vacated 2024 Rule."

Last verified 2026-10-26. Not legal or tax advice.

Is my "comfort club" with two tune-ups and 15 percent off repairs a service contract?

In Texas, Nevada and New York, a plan that provides only scheduled maintenance is carved out, and a discount on your own pricing is not a promise to repair. In Florida the exemption holds only under one year, with no indemnification and a discount of 20 percent or less, so 15 percent qualifies. California's definition covers maintenance contracts; check with the Bureau of Household Goods and Services before selling.

What if I promise "no charge for repairs under $200"?

That is indemnification. It is a service contract or service warranty in every state in the table and needs registration or licensure and reimbursement insurance or reserves.

Can I charge monthly instead of annually?

Yes, and it reduces the deferred-revenue balance the financial-security rules measure. It does not change whether the plan is a service contract; that depends on what it promises.

Do I pay income tax on the whole year's plan fee up front?

Cash method: yes, when received. Accrual method: the unearned part may be deferred to the next year under Treasury Regulation 1.451-8, and no further.

Can I auto-renew?

With clear terms disclosed before sign-up, affirmative consent, an acknowledgment that includes how to cancel, and, for online sign-ups, online cancellation (California B&P 17602). Other states have similar laws; the FTC's 2024 federal rule was vacated and a 2026 rulemaking is open.

Is a manufacturer's extended warranty I resell the same thing?

Reselling someone else's service contract makes you a seller under most of these statutes, with its own registration in several states. Read the provider's agreement and your state's seller rules.

Sources

  1. Texas Occupations Code §1304.003
  2. Texas Occupations Code §1304.004
  3. Texas Occupations Code §1304.101
  4. Florida Statutes §634.401
  5. Florida Statutes §634.403
  6. Nevada NRS ch. 690C
  7. New York Insurance Law §7902
  8. New York Insurance Law §7907
  9. Arizona A.R.S. §20-1095
  10. Arizona A.R.S. §20-1095.01
  11. Illinois 215 ILCS 152/5
  12. Illinois 215 ILCS 152/5 152/15
  13. California Civil Code §1791
  14. California Civil Code B&P §9855
  15. California Civil Code §9855.1
  16. California Civil Code §9855.2
  17. California Civil Code §17602
  18. IRS Publication 538
  19. IRS Publication 538 Treas. Reg. §1.451-8
  20. FTC, ANPRM on negative option marketing (2026-03-11)
  21. NAIC Service Contracts Model Act (#685)

Related Reading

Free contractor software by trade